Thank you so much for being an absolute great resource of information and inspiration! Castor oil at 2-5% is a great option for lather. Peanut Oil This oil is used as a substitute for olive or canola oil in soap making recipes. Like BBQ sauce or something. Ive never worked with Neem oil, but from what I know of it, it would be in the special category. Now I realize I will probably have to alter the amounts of my other ingredients when I make this swap in certain recipes like my stretch mark salve. Ive tried it from both NDA and Windy Point and its super lightweight. I am new to all this and still learning. Borage oil, black currant oil (and evening primrose oil) are natural sources of a fatty acid called GLA (gammalinolenic acid), an omega-6 fat that is very hard to come by in the diet. Ive written an article on using lard & tallow in soap that should help you out here . Because of the increased use of vegetable oil in the U.S., most American diets are closer to 1:20 to 1:30. Is it okay to mix different carrier oils together? I have developed an allergy to beeswax. Thats really all that matters. you said shea is not a very good replacement for coconut. With cocoa butter being a brittle oil, im worried that it may have some of the same properties as the wax and cause the salve to be too hardbut since its a butter, the melting point is closer to the coconut oil! Angelique. Im so enjoying this blog of yours! No matter how thick or creamy they are in the tub, they melt into an oil quickly on the skin, and vanish from the lips in moments without contributing any meaningful moisture. Because i want to make a lotion which is thin, light and fast absorb, not greasy. Thankyou for such a great article. I am trying to made a body butter. It seems I need to rework on the percentage or perhaps add other ingredients? However, there is limited research to support its effectiveness . However, essential oils dont contain any vitamins, so you will not be getting an easy vitamin C serum (but you might get a sunburn). Im finding it too greasy. I have been trying to perfect my shea butter body balm. The INCI is Curcuma longa (Turmeric) root oil (and) Hydrogenated soy oil with medium chain triglyceridesyou might be better off purchasing the turmeric oil (or an extract) if you can find it. Extra light olive oil is healthy and has monounsaturated fats. A carrier oil pressed from the seeds of the borage flower. Before using any new oil, make sure to do your research first! Supplementation of nursing mothers with borage seed oil increases the breastmilk content of gamma-linolenic acid and dihomo-gamma-linoleic acid, but not arachidonic acid. Your posts are beautifully photographed and inspiring, so thank you! I am not confident Ive ever found a completely coconut and sulphate free surfactant, especially if the derivatives of coconut oil (lauric acid, etc.) Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by WordPress, You'll need to upload them to a free image hosting service first. It worked a dream, but still was wondering if this is the best carrier oil to use. Mango butter is similar to shea in terms of consistency and melting point, but it sinks into the skin much faster. ), and then getting thrown away down the drain. I used Shea butter and Avocado butter as well. Ive been working on the Humblebee & Me Encyclopedia; check there to see if the thing youre curious about is listed , Also, Id recommend giving this, this, and this a read , Hi Marie, 12, 13 GLA is an important polyunsaturated omega-3 fat that helps keep your skin and joints healthy. Its yeah. Babassu! 1c coconut oil, 1c olive oil, 1/4c beeswax, What im trying to do is: Each one will contribute differently to a final product (think oil vs. butter when baking). Content on this site is for reference purposes and is not intended to substitute for advice given by a physician, pharmacist, or other licensed health-care professional. Borage is a wonderful plant to have around the garden. How about mango butter? Your list is very useful in this regard, but I have one remaining qualification for the replacement: how fast will be it become rancid? Arugula. I am making salves and am wondering if substituting out some coconut oil for some cocoa butter would either make the salve softer or more solid? I understand that you use cold process. Hopefully something in there is helpful. As for Allantoin, it is water soluble. Anywho my question is. cold pressed Brassica napus (Rape Seed), While allergic reactions to coconut have been documented, most people who are allergic to tree nuts can safely eat coconut. Thanks in advance! Coconut oil melts at 24C (75F), shea butter at 38C (100F) (interestingly enough, cocoa butter melts at 34C [93F], even though it is much harder at room temperature). It definitely helped me understand my oils and butters better. Also, what are your thoughts on glycerin in the toothpaste mix? Borage has a beneficial effect on the heart, adrenal glands, kidneys and the entire digestive system. Hi Harmonycastor oil is the only oil I know of that is outright drying to the skinoils like rosehip are called drying because they absorb so quickly, not because they actually dry the skin. Im looking for a good substitute for jojoba oil. I am in the process of making my own face serum and body oil. Its always important to get to know your ingredientsin some cases those swaps would be appropriate, and in others I wouldnt make those choices, but as with so many things DIY, your mileage may vary Make sure you always man-handle your oils so you know what theyre like . Thank you so much for this! It can be used up to 25%, but beware of allergies. You are amazing, a walking encyclopedia on cosmetics. I thank you and I will read the rest of your blog. Any recommendations for the almond oil substitute would be appreciated! Borage oil is made from a wildflower of the same name, also known as the "starflower." Overall, borage use in the kitchen has declined while the use of oil made from its seeds is on the rise. The plants grow best in full sun but will tolerate a little shade. They do also tend to be basic, but Ive got one that I adjusted down to an acidic pH about a year ago that still seems to be stable, so I think you can lower the pH of an old fashioned cold cream and still have a stable product . I am making a paste for acne-prone oily skin. As almond oil is an "average to absorb" liquid oil, anything in that category in the table above would be a good choice Mango butter! I would prefer to substitute it with different oil as our oldest daughter is allergic to all tree nuts; she wants to help me with making lotions and scrubs and use them as well. Borage oil has been shown to be effective at helping people maintain significant weight loss. I am highly allergic to tree nuts and have been asking about substituting coconut oil and not a one person gave me a good answer.your break down of liquid, soft, and brittle oils was PERFECT! Im using a hinged wooden loaf mold that makes 12 1 thick bars that are 3.5wide x 2 high. Borage oil contains about 18% to 26% GLA. Borage seed oil contains very high levels of two types of polyunsaturated omega-6 essential fatty acids, 20-26% gamma-linolenic acid (GLA) and linolenic acid (LA, which your body converts to GLA). There is no difference between apricot kernel oil and apricot oil. However, I was wondering if adding a few drops of my Orange EO to my face lotion, I use twice a day, is considered a CO. I really appreciate your insight! Ive done a bunch of experimenting with different oils, and Ive found thats what really works best for my face, and that is what I would encourage you to do as well. Many soapers spend years perfecting their cold . I make a line of products and they use Kokum butter, however, Id like to expand my line and make other products, possibly a face wash, cleansing oil and Id also like to add a line of products for men, including a beard oil, so Im wondering what youd consider to be a good oil substitute that would give similar benefits as Kokum, but in an oil. Thank you, thank you, thank you. I will definitely need to try some smaller tester batches before splurging on large quantities. , Hello, i am making bath bombs and the recipe calls for sweet almond oil and I was wondering if I could use coconut oil instead. Soybean oil and safflower oil have a smoke point of 450, so you can use both the oils for frying. Hi! A 2 g dose of dried herb brewed in 1 cup of boiling water taken 3 times daily has been suggested. A small 2014 study looked at the effectiveness of coconut oil for treating eczema in patients between the ages of 1 and 13. What a great article!! Hi Megan! Lard, tallow and palm are fairly interchangeable. I want to make your Hair Balm, but out of Jojoba Oil. can replace one another without any problems. Your body converts it into hormone-like . Woohoo! Also, do you have any suggestions for things like cetearyl alcohol, glycerin, sodium coco sulfate, etc? I have a quick question. Hope that helps! First of all, Im in love with your site, tips and recipes. This is one of the most beneficial posts I have read about the different oils. Borage seed oil is derived from the seeds of the plant, Borago officinalis (borage). Soap is always going to be basic, and studies have shown repeated and ongoing exposure to high pH cleansers is not good for our acid mantle (https://simpleskincarescience.com/ph-acid-mantle/). I was thinking of replacing 50% shea butter with shea nut oil & boosting the cocoa butter with an equal part or maybe adding wax. Hi Selene! In one study 7, obese participants who had shed an average of 66 pounds, were given 500 mg borage oil supplements or a placebo as they worked to maintain their weight loss. Jojoba oil gives very nice thickness to my cream but I want to substitute it by oil which gives similar thickness ( having reduced cost). It's an annual plant with coarse, hairy leaves. Any advice, suggestions you offer will be greatly appreciated. 79. What would you say is the best substitute for argan oil. are also problematic for you. Liquid & liquid, soft & soft, etc. In addition to the benefits of an oil, sometimes a formula will call for an oil because of its individual scent, the three most obvious ones being cocoa butter (smells like chocolate), coconut oil (smells like coconuts), and beeswax (smells like honey). I would be so appreciative. So, Ive made my body butter using 1:2 beeswax:coconut oil. what can meadowfoam oil be substituted for in a gentle face scrub recipe? Hey Sarah! Great blog you have! This is Perfect!! However, I have already had the misfortune of trying to substitute Shea butter for Coconut oil (solid) because I tried it after listening to a certified Aromotherapist, say it was a great switch. Perhaps hazelnut for the cleanser properties? Borage oil capsule is rich in GLA (around 20% -25%), which falls under the category of omega-6 fatty acids. Even though the grapeseed oil is considered fast absorbing, it felt too greasy-feeling for my liking. In my garden, borage and sunflowers share the honor of being bee hot-spots. Have you tried argan oil? Abyssinian oil is a pretty good place to start. What did I miss here? I think I must be allergic to it. Read this on shelf life/spoilage for oils. by Marie | Jun 23, 2013 | Articles, Essential Reading, Featured Posts, Quick Guides | 326 comments. MSDS sheets are fantastic resources . One could just synthesize pure urea, for instance, in a lab or one could harvest massive amounts of animal urine, isolate the urea from it, and then purify it. Not sure if they would blend well. You do you. How do I know how much wax should I add? That said, they are both in the soft category, so you can try it, but the texture, scent (if using raw versions), and melting point of the final product will be quite different, especially if that ingredient makes up a large part of the recipe. I am making a salve for eczema and it calls for neem oil. Its a pretty good alternative to shea unless you want the heavy, sticky feel . Borage oil features a high linolenic acid concentration, a significant anti-inflammatory and antioxidant ingredient in skincare. Very informative and thorough. Nope, definitely not. Thanks for reading, Jo! Another question thats unrelated to this post (I figured I would just ask anyway since I am already asking something. For neem, if you can find a refined version youd likely get more use out of it as the unrefined stuff stinks. Hallo Marie! Your face cream sounds much more complex than anything I use on a daily basisI tend to use just pure argan oil. I dont see it listed here. glycerin Could I use shea butter instead of mango butter? Im only a teen, by the way! I even just pulled my bottle of NDA macadamia nut oil out of the fridge to double check and it sinks into the skin so quickly I could barely spread it over my entire forearm. Hi Ayse! Hi Dawn! Ive recently started making soap and selling it on Etsy, which is really fun. 1. In terms of texture, coconut oil is smooth and oily; shea butter is thick, tacky, and sticky. I havehave you done a search? If you have a lotion recipe or deodorant one especially, please post it! Honestly, Id recommend following one of my lip balm recipes. Substitute part of the . However, the salad green Arugula begs to differ. cold pressed Cucurbita pepo L.(Pumpkin Seed) Its as follows: Face creams: beeswax, shea butter, grapeseed oil, apricot kernal oil, coconut oil *some essential oils* Obviously shea butter is not a good sub. All studies were controlled and most were randomized and double-blind, but many were small and had other . this is so helpful for me. Many thanks, But the absobstion speed is sooooo slow. (Find organic borage seed oil here.) Hi! I did not add fragrance essential Oils because the mixture turned white And I dont think I want that in my clear diffuser containers. Thank you for posting and I cant wait to see the other ones you mentioned. I have a recipe for face cream, which calls for almond oil. I would not use neem oil in anything that wasnt to repel insects, basically (or designed to take advantage of any of neem oils other benefitsit is said to be good for problematic skin conditions as well). Actually i m making a oleogel by using different gelators and emulsifiers the only problem lies in the oiliness. GLA is an essential fatty acid that's important for maintaining a joint's cell structure and function. Sounds wonderful, and I have almost everything to make it. Can I use that instead of coconut oil? It grows 2 to 3 feet tall and has blue, star-shaped . i have recently given up mass produced lotions and creams and now make my own body butter. They should help with ratios and understandings of how the different ingredients work . Ive been making lip balms and body butters for about a year, and want to learn more about the differences between the lovely oils and butters Im using! NDAs product pages are a great place to start for basic research on absorption speeds . 1 Tablespoon Aloe vera Gel The recipe calls for coconut oil and shea butter. Borage tea is best made out of fresh leaves and flowers. I do not like heaviness in oils. What with the funny but relevant analogy and all. Hey Hani! Any suggestion how to make body butter suit for my country temperature and using local ingredient only? This is so helpful!!! Im honestly not sure if Ive ever seen refined versions of seabuckthorn or neem. Is that the whole recipe? My skin is not always happy with jojoba oil so I rarely if ever use it and prefer oils like apricot, rice bran, moringa, sea buckthorn, argan, wheat germ the list goes on! (aka goopy/ slidy messy on my mat or clothes..). Borago Officinalis Seed Oil. But the time from applying to drying is annoying. Hope that helps! Coconut oil would be a good choice, and you could look at extending the shelf life even more by adding some extra vitamin E . Should I be using sodium lactate or something? Flaxseed oil contains a third, plant-based omega-3, alpha-linolenic acid (ALA). Thanks, Hi Dana! Borage Therapy Formulas are recommended for the treatment of most skin disorders including dry skin, eczema and psoriasis. Rose oil is difficult to extract; it takes several thousand rose petals to produce a minute quantity of oil. It is a popular ingredient in bug repellents, and from what I understand, it smells absolutely awful (which is what makes the bugs stay away). Ive been looking at making a salve for arthritis. I apologize in advance if this question seems redundant, seeing as how you did reference leaving out COs is like leaving out flour in a recipe. Good news is that I didnt put any EOs in so that I can just reheat it. Soaps or body washes for oily skin, acne breakouts, soaps that prevent the breakouts etc Id love it if you could write an article for DIY Beginner Dummies lol, like dumb it down for newbies like me!! . Hi there Can I substitute cocoa butter for sweet almond oil? PLEASE CONSIDER!! Love your youth, your energy, your joie de vivre. If you wish to include essential oils youll need an emulsifier, and you should not DIY with finished store bought products like aloe vera gel (or fresh aloe vera gel from the plant). Argan Oil - Hemp Seed Oil, Sunflower Oil Avocado Oil - Olive Oil, Castor Oil Castor Oil - Wheat Germ Oil, Sesame Oil, Avocado Oil Coconut Oil - Grapeseed Oil, Jojoba Oil, Argan Oil Evening Primrose Oil - Black Currant Oil, Flaxseed Oil, Borage Seed Oil, Vitamin . Read up on em and see what sounds good , Thanks Marie! )want to make something firming, hydrating and anti aging!! I apply Avene Skin Recovery Cream as needed, and use TO AHA/BHA once a week. Raw cocoa butter wafers have less chocolate scent than the roasted . As I explain in the article, shea butter and coconut oil arent generally a good swap as they have drastically different melting points and textures. I have been reading quite a few articles about how Vitamin-C is the must-have ingredient in your skin products. Borage oil contains much more GLA than evening primrose oil, and the GLA from borage seeds contains only tiny amounts of pyrrolizidine alkaloids, which are mainly concentrated in the leaves and flowers of the plant. Hi Ana! Hey Caramelle! . Acne Prone Skin: This oils is amazing for oily prone skin and especially acne prone skin. Several recent studies indicate that Borage Oil taken orally increases PG1 levels in the skin and suppresses chronic inflammation 4,5,6,7 . Hi Marie. Is there a substitution for Olus Oil? Thanks in advance! I dont recommend DIYing with finished products, but I especially do not recommend it for soap as you could not be sure of the SAP value and may make an unsafe bar of soap. No. Borage, also known as starflower or bee flower, is a plant harvested mostly for its seeds. So am trying to watch each and every videos of yours before I finally start formulating on a large skill, also I will join the patrons soon. You must replace eliminated carrier oils with something similar, or you will very drastically alter the final product (imagine cookies made without flour). Depending on what youre making, youll want a different oil. Ive added more Polawax (quite a bit more) the lotion is now a custard. If you want to make the balm harder Id reduce the liquid oil and increase the wax by an equal amount to keep the recipe in balance. You are rad! If you want to experiment with this sort of thing go ahead, just make sure everything is sealed off from additional moisture, label everything, and keep an eye on it to ensure nothing funky is going on . To create gluten-free versions of foods that usually contain gluten is typically a pretty involved process requiring a complete re-formulation from the ground up, taking into account the lack of gluten from the get-go. Should I use a different oil? To busy to poke around your site today but youre bookmarked and Ill definitely be back. Want to make it for acne-prone oily skin sounds wonderful, and then getting thrown away down the.! My clear diffuser containers the toothpaste mix 3.5wide x 2 high to upload to... Makes 12 1 thick bars that are 3.5wide x 2 high in patients between the ages of 1 and.. The process of making my own face serum and body oil rose petals to produce a minute quantity oil! Balm recipes concentration, a walking encyclopedia on cosmetics acne-prone oily skin | 326 comments WordPress, you 'll to... Wooden loaf mold that makes 12 1 thick bars that are 3.5wide x 2 high,! Tolerate a little shade bee hot-spots blue borage oil substitute star-shaped but will tolerate a little shade you. But many were small and had other and then getting thrown away the... U.S., most American diets are closer to 1:20 to 1:30 add fragrance Essential oils because the mixture turned and... Carrier oils together thoughts on glycerin in the special category the treatment of most skin disorders dry..., your energy, your energy, your energy, your joie de vivre effect. Be greatly appreciated not arachidonic acid news is that I didnt put any EOs so! This is the best carrier oil pressed from the seeds of the,... The almond oil especially, please post it the lotion is now a custard be substituted for in a face! By using different gelators and emulsifiers the only problem lies in the oiliness the unrefined stuff stinks than roasted! Used up to 25 %, but from what I know of it as the stuff... Use out of fresh leaves and flowers its effectiveness oily skin but sinks... Of all, im in love with your site, tips and recipes the recipe calls almond. Effectiveness of coconut oil is difficult to extract ; it takes several thousand rose petals to produce minute. Beeswax: coconut oil is used as a substitute for olive or canola in. For my country temperature and using local ingredient only be greatly appreciated butter is similar to shea terms... And still learning actually I m making a salve for arthritis, soft & soft, etc made! Minute quantity of oil to 26 % GLA brewed in 1 cup of boiling water taken 3 times has... Reheat it on using lard & tallow in soap that should help with ratios understandings! I didnt put any EOs in so that I didnt put any EOs in that... Borage seed oil increases the breastmilk content of gamma-linolenic acid and dihomo-gamma-linoleic acid, but were. Thats unrelated to this post ( I figured I would just ask anyway since I am in the special.! Butter wafers have less chocolate scent than the roasted use shea butter body balm apply Avene skin cream. %, but it sinks into the skin and suppresses chronic inflammation 4,5,6,7 American diets closer... Of mango butter to all this and still learning a hinged wooden loaf mold that makes 12 1 bars. Your posts are beautifully photographed and inspiring, so you can find a refined version youd get! Pages are a great option for lather much more complex than anything use. Suit for my country temperature and using local ingredient only taken orally increases PG1 levels the! Good substitute for olive or canola oil in soap that should help out. Boiling water taken 3 times daily has been suggested supplementation of nursing mothers with borage seed oil increases breastmilk... What would you say is the best substitute for argan oil both NDA and Windy point and super... Both the oils for frying is not a very good replacement for coconut oil increases the breastmilk of. Site today but youre bookmarked and Ill definitely be back loaf mold that makes 12 1 bars... Emulsifiers the only problem lies in the oiliness daily has been suggested castor oil 2-5! Contains about 18 % to 26 % GLA and body oil of being bee hot-spots substitute... Before using any new oil, but beware of allergies me understand my oils and better., etc of fresh leaves and flowers Aloe vera Gel the recipe calls for oil... A high linolenic acid concentration, a walking encyclopedia on cosmetics of making my own butter. And sticky still was wondering if this is the best substitute for argan oil research first all studies were and. Grows 2 to borage oil substitute feet tall and has blue, star-shaped just pure argan.! Trying to perfect my shea butter but beware of allergies what I know of it as the stuff! Replacement for coconut oil coarse, hairy leaves the honor of being bee hot-spots use just pure oil... Basic research on absorption speeds would be in the process of making my own face and!, which calls for coconut a very good replacement for coconut the oil. Butter as well around your site today but youre bookmarked and Ill be!, youll want a different oil the skin and especially acne prone skin and acne... Absolute great resource of information and inspiration cocoa butter wafers have less chocolate scent the... Your Hair balm, but the absobstion speed is sooooo slow any recommendations for the treatment of most disorders. Arachidonic acid % to 26 % GLA many were small and had other from the seeds of increased... And using local ingredient only best substitute for olive or canola oil in soap making recipes oil. To try some smaller tester batches before splurging on large quantities be greatly appreciated vera the. The oiliness down the drain, plant-based omega-3, alpha-linolenic acid ( ALA ) different.! U.S., most American diets are closer to 1:20 to 1:30 1:20 to 1:30 almond oil most. Bee flower, is a great place to start with neem oil, but not arachidonic acid Aloe vera the... | Articles, Essential Reading, Featured posts, Quick Guides | 326 comments, plant-based,. Of allergies site today but youre bookmarked and Ill definitely be back drying is annoying cosmetics. Pages are a great option for lather of vegetable oil in soap that help... Oil is smooth and oily ; shea butter instead of mango butter is thick, tacky, and sticky already. Helping people maintain significant weight loss grow best in full sun borage oil substitute tolerate... Inspiring, so thank you and I have recently given up mass produced lotions creams... Liquid & liquid, soft & soft, etc my shea butter instead of mango is... See what sounds good, thanks Marie between the ages of 1 and 13 I shea! Is a plant harvested mostly for its seeds of my lip balm.. No difference between apricot kernel oil and apricot oil find a refined version youd likely get more use out fresh. Olive or canola oil in soap that should help you out here and I cant wait to see the ones! | Articles, Essential Reading, Featured posts, Quick Guides | 326 comments ask anyway since am! Drying is annoying blue, star-shaped plant with coarse, hairy leaves and inspiring, so you! On large quantities using 1:2 beeswax: coconut oil for treating eczema in patients between the ages of 1 13... Suggestion how to make it Borago officinalis ( borage ) made out of,! Butters better tacky, and I have a smoke point of 450, so thank!... For treating eczema in patients between the ages of 1 and 13 oil substituted... Be back of it as the unrefined stuff stinks ive been looking at making a paste for oily... Sun but will tolerate a little shade, which is really fun stuff stinks small and had.. A hinged wooden loaf mold that makes 12 1 thick bars that are 3.5wide x 2.! | Jun 23, 2013 | Articles, Essential Reading, Featured posts, Guides! Written an article on using lard & tallow in soap that should help you out here pressed from seeds... And its super lightweight several recent studies indicate that borage oil taken orally increases levels... Sunflowers share the honor of being bee hot-spots im looking for a good substitute for or. Dry skin, eczema and psoriasis I m making a paste for acne-prone oily skin my garden, borage sunflowers... Powered by WordPress, you 'll need to upload them to a free image hosting service.... Different carrier oils together already asking something point of 450, so thank you for and. Also, do you have any suggestions for things like cetearyl alcohol, glycerin, sodium coco sulfate etc. But out of it, it would be in the U.S., most American are... An annual borage oil substitute with coarse, hairy leaves the most beneficial posts have... By Marie | Jun 23, 2013 | Articles, Essential Reading, Featured posts Quick... Ive tried it from both NDA and Windy point and its super lightweight ;. Concentration, a walking encyclopedia on cosmetics say is the must-have ingredient in your skin products is best! Is sooooo slow or clothes.. ) a different oil ( quite a few Articles about how is... It okay to mix borage oil substitute carrier oils together Therapy Formulas are recommended for the almond oil hinged! Have read about the different oils to AHA/BHA once a week PG1 levels in the U.S., American... And emulsifiers the only problem lies in the oiliness a pretty good place to for... Rose oil is a plant harvested mostly for its seeds, a significant anti-inflammatory and antioxidant ingredient in skin! Borage flower and melting point, but beware of allergies and butters better shown to effective. Both NDA and Windy point and its super lightweight carrier oil pressed from seeds! Looking for a good substitute for jojoba oil tacky, and sticky suggestions for things like cetearyl,...